5 Best Non-Toxic Bakeware Brand Picks for 2024

You just want to bake your cupcakes and safely eat them too… Is that too much to ask?

You deserve to eat those delicious cupcakes AND to use bakeware that isn’t laden with toxic chemicals that leech into them.

In this article, I’ll break down the good, the bad, and the ugly of bakeware on the market today so you know what to look for, what to avoid completely, and how to navigate the green-washing that’s inevitably coming your way.

Safe, environmental, delicious baking.

Easy-peasy lemon(bar) squeezy.

Grab what you need from my round-up of the best non-toxic bakeware brands and get back to baking!

What Are the Best Non Toxic Bakeware Brand Picks?

Some of the best non-toxic bakeware brands include Great Jones, Le Creuset, Caraway, and more. These brands use materials that are free from harmful chemicals like PFOA, and PTFE ensuring that your food is safe and healthy.

Check out the full list below of my top brand picks for every kind of baker and in every safe-to-use bakeware material:

1. Best Overall

Caraway 11-Piece Full Bakeware Set

This set is a non-toxic, non-stick, and ceramic-coated bakeware set made of aluminized steel body. 

Set Includes:

• 18×13 baking sheet
• 10×15 baking sheet
• 12-cup muffin pan
• 9×13 rectangle pan
• 18×13 cooling rack
• 9″ square pan
• 1 lb load pan
• (2) 9″ cake pans
• (2) organizers

Pros and Cons

• Non-toxic and non-stick ceramic coating makes baking and cleaning easy and healthy.
• The aluminized steel body ensures even heat distribution, resulting in perfectly baked goods every time. (Oven safe up to 550F).
• These cookie sheets won’t warp like aluminum baking sheets.
• Includes an assortment of baking pans, cooling racks, and storage, making it a complete solution for all your baking needs.
• The set comes with cabinet organizers, making it super compact and easy to store in the bottom of your cabinet.
• The set is available in nine beautiful colors, allowing you to choose one that matches your kitchen decor.
• The manufacturing process releases 60% less CO2 into the atmosphere compared to traditional non-stick pans, making it an eco-friendly choice.
• Not dishwasher safe
• Ceramic coating loses non-stick quality over time
• Outside paint can chip
• Made in China, which may be a consideration for some customers.

Buy Now

This set is priced at $395

• Free Shipping over $90, Free Returns & 30-Day Trial

 Bottom Line:

The Caraway 11-piece full bakeware set is ideal for those who want a complete solution for all their non-toxic baking needs.

I love the way this set, in the color sage, matches the potted ivy hanging in my kitchen window. But more than that, I love that I can rest assured, my baked goods aren’t toxic!

Also, who can resist matching cookware and bakeware? Yes, Caraway has cookware too!

2. Best for Durability

Le Creuset Enameled Cast Iron

Le Creuset’s enameled cast iron Round Dutch Oven is an iconic kitchen tool that is indispensable for home bakers and professional chefs alike and is designed to last a lifetime.

Available In:

• 2 quart
• 3.5 quart
• 4.5 quart
• 5.5 quart
• 7.25 quart
• 9 quart
• 13.25 quart

Pros and Cons

• Comes with a lifetime limited warranty, providing peace of mind and confidence in your investment.
• Superior heat retention and distribution for even cooking and browning.
• Super versatile and ideal for baking bread, biscuits, cobblers, cakes, brownies, pizza, and more!
• Durable enamel coating resists chipping and cracking, ensuring long-lasting use and easy cleaning.
• Compatible with all cooktops, including induction, and oven safe up to 500°F.
• Stylish design that can go from oven/stovetop to tabletop, making it perfect for serving and entertaining.
• Available in a whopping 25 colors to match any kitchen décor.
• Le Creuset’s Dutch ovens are top-of-the-line and are quite expensive compared to other brands.
• Cast iron is quite heavy, which may make the Dutch oven difficult for some people to handle, especially when it’s full.
• Cast iron takes longer to heat up compared to other materials, which may not be ideal for those who need to cook quickly.

Buy Now

The price range for this Dutch oven is $260 – $625

• Free Shipping over $99, Lifetime Warranty

Bottom Line:

Le Creuset’s Dutch oven is best suited for someone who wants to invest in a long-lasting, high-quality piece of bakeware that can be passed down for generations. Personally, I always choose longevity when making a purchase – this is one of the most sustainable ways to shop!

3. Best Budget

OXO 14-Piece Bake & Store

This set is made from borosilicate glass. The containers in the set come with leak-proof lids that have tabs for easy opening and closing. 

3 Qt Baking Dish with Lid, a 2 Qt Baking Dish with Lid, Loaf Pan, Pie Plate, 1 Cup Round Smart Seal Container, 2 Cup Round Smart Seal Container, and 4 Cup Round Smart Seal Container.

Set Includes:

• 3 qt baking dish w/lid
• 2 qt baking dish w/lid
• Loaf pan
• Pie plate
• 1 Cup round smart seal container
• 2 Cup round smart seal container
• 4 Cup round smart seal container

Pros and Cons

• The containers are made from durable borosilicate glass, which is oven, microwave, freezer, and dishwasher safe, making them versatile and easy to use.
• The leak-proof lids with tabs make it easy to open and close the containers, ensuring that food stays fresh and organized.
• An affordable option for bakeware
• OXO is a “For The Planet” company
• Glass bakeware may be more prone to breaking or shattering compared to other materials, such as metal or ceramic.
• Glass bakeware may not distribute heat as evenly as other materials, which can result in uneven cooking or baking.
• Glass bakeware may take longer to preheat compared to metal bakeware, which can impact cooking times.

Buy Now

This set is priced at $79.99

• Free Shipping over $49

Bottom Line:

The OXO 14-piece bakeware set is ideal for someone looking for a budget option bakeware set. There are no bells and whistles here, just simple baking at an affordable price. Although, I will say, I am impressed that OXO is a “For The Planet” member and they donate 1% of annual sales to environmental nonprofits. Points for sustainability!

4. Best for Show

Great Jones Fully Baked

Great Jones Fully Baked Bakeware set is a comprehensive collection of seven essential mixed-material baking pieces. The set’s vibrant colors and stylish design make it a perfect addition to a kitchen you’ll want to show off. 

Set Includes:

• 18×13 Baking Sheet
• (2) Bread Pans
• (2) Cake Pans
• Pie Pan
• 9×13 Casserole Dish

Pros and Cons

• The set’s vibrant colors and stylish design make it a beautiful addition to any kitchen, adding a pop of color and personality to your baking routine.
• The set’s versatility provides everything home bakers need in one convenient set.
• Heavy-duty aluminized steel ensures even heating and long-lasting performance, making it a reliable option for frequent bakers.
• The ceramic non-stick coating allows for an easy release of baked goods, making clean-up a breeze and reducing the need for excess oil or butter.
• The set is dishwasher safe, making it easy to clean and maintain (although their website says they recommend hand washing).
• The non-stick coating may not be as durable as other types of bakeware and may wear off over time with frequent use.
• The set’s bright colors may not be to everyone’s taste and may clash with some kitchen decor.

Buy Now

This set is priced at $215

• Free shipping over $100, 60-day trial, Free returns

Bottom Line:

The Great Jones Fully Baked bakeware set is best suited for individuals who are looking for a well-rounded set of baking tools that are show-worthy at an affordable price. One thing that sets this company apart, in my eyes, is that it is women-owned.

5. Best for Basics

Caraway 5-piece Half Bakeware Set

This set is made with carbon steel and a non-toxic ceramic coating and offers a minimalist approach to baking.

Set Includes:

• 18×13 Baking Sheet
• 10×15 Baking Sheet
• 12 Cup Muffin Pan
• 9×13 Rectangle Pan
• Cabinet Organizer

Pros and Cons

• Non-toxic and non-stick ceramic coating makes baking and cleaning easy and healthy.
• The aluminized steel body ensures even heat distribution, resulting in perfectly baked goods every time. (Oven safe up to 550F).
• The set includes the basics of what you’ll need to bake your favorites and nothing more making it ideal for the minimalist kitchen.
• It comes with cabinet organizers, making it super compact and easy to store in the bottom of your cabinet.
• The set is available in seven beautiful colors, allowing you to choose one that matches your kitchen decor.
• The manufacturing process releases 60% less CO2 into the atmosphere compared to traditional non-stick pans, making it an eco-friendly choice.
• The ceramic coating may not be as durable as other types of coatings and may wear off over time.
• The set is not dishwasher safe and must be hand washed, which can be inconvenient for some users.
• The half-sheet pan may not fit in some smaller ovens, which could limit its use for some bakers.
• The set only includes five pieces, which may not be enough for more advanced bakers who need a wider range of bakeware sizes and shapes.

Buy Now

This set is priced at $245

• Free Shipping over $90, Free Returns & 30-Day Trial

Bottom Line:

The Caraway 5-piece Half Bakeware set is ideal for casual home bakers who are looking for an aesthetic and high-quality set of essentials for easy baking and clean up. This set is on my personal wish list as it hits the mark for sustainability, aesthetics, and functionality for my basic baking needs.

Best Non-Toxic Baking Sheet and Cookie Sheets

Caraway Baking Sheet Duo

Caraway Large Baking Sheet (18″x13″)

Caraway Medium Baking Sheet (15″x10″)

Great Jones’ Sheet Shw (3-pack)

Great Jones’ Large Sheet & Cooling Rack

Best Non-Toxic Loaf Pan & Baking Pan

XTREMA IS ON SALE NOW!!

20% OFF SITE WIDE: 3% of every order will be donated to the Farmlink Project

Dates of Sale: 4/19-4/30

Xtrema Pure Cermaic Baker’s Bundle

Xtrema Pure Ceramic Single Loaf Pan

Xtrema Pure Ceramic Baking Pan Bundle

Great Jones Stoneware Sweeties Set

9″x 13″ Casserole Dish, Pie Dish

What are the Safest Bakeware Materials for Non Toxic Baking?

There are several types of bakeware made from materials to choose from, each with its unique benefits.

Ceramic bakeware is a popular option due to its non-stick and easy to clean properties. 

Glass bakeware is another popular choice as it is non-porous, easy to clean, and budget friendly.

Stainless steel bakeware is durable and long-lasting, making it a great investment for avid bakers. Stainless steel baking sheets are far less likely to warp – Holy non-toxic baking sheet!

Cast iron bakeware is the most durable, has excellent heat distribution, and is great for getting a crispy crust on bread and pies.

Stoneware is a good choice for casserole lovers because it offers even browning and easy cleanup.

Silicone bakeware is ideal because of its durability and flexibility. This makes it easy to remove delicate cakes, muffins, and bread without damage.

By selecting the safest bakeware materials, we can reduce our exposure to harmful chemicals while still enjoying delicious baked goods.

Check out my top picks for the best non toxic bakeware by material category below!

Top Picks for Bakeware for Your Kitchen by Material:

What Is the Best Ceramic Bakeware?

Top Pick: Caraway Cermaic Coated Non-Stick Muffin Pan

Second Pick: Our Place Oven Pan

What Is the Best Glass Bakeware?

Top Pick: OXO Glass 3 qt Baking Dish

Second Pick: Pyrex Deep Two Piece Baking Dish

What Is the Best Stainless Steel Glass Bakeware?

Top Pick: All Clad Stainless Steel Roasting Sheet

Second Pick: Team Far Stainless Steel Bakeware Set

What Is the Best Cast Iron Bakeware?

Top Pick: Le Creuset Oval Dutch Oven

Second Pick: Staub 7 Qt Round Dutch Oven

What Is the Best Stoneware Bakeware?

Top Pick: Made In 3-piece Bakeware Set

Second Pick: Le Creuset Heritage Casserole Dish

What Is the Best Silicone Bakeware?

Top Pick: Silpat Muffin Pan

Second Pick: Trudeau Silicone Muffin Pan

What Is Non-Toxic Bakeware?

Non-toxic bakeware is a safe and healthy alternative to traditional bakeware, which can release harmful chemicals and toxic fumes when heated to high temperatures. 

There are various types of safe bakeware available, including ceramic, glass, cast iron, and stainless steel.

These options are gaining popularity due to growing concerns over the potential health risks associated with traditional bakeware that often contains harmful chemicals such as lead, cadmium, and PFOA.

Non-Stick Bakeware – Is it Safe?

Nonstick bakeware has been a popular choice for baking enthusiasts for years, but it comes with a hidden danger.

The chemicals used to make non-stick coatings, such as PFOA, have been linked to health problems and are considered toxic materials.

Studies have shown that when non-stick bakeware is heated to high temperatures, these chemicals can be released into the air and leeched into food.

People are turning to the safest bakeware available. And with the rise of non-toxic bakeware options, the toxic stuff is becoming outdated.

It’s time to leave toxic non-stick baking options behind and prioritize our health and well-being!

What’s the Sustainability Factor?

Sustainability is a key factor to consider when choosing between non-toxic and non-stick bakeware.

Non-toxic options are typically produced using environmentally friendly manufacturing processes that minimize waste and reduce carbon footprints.

Additionally, these materials are often more durable and longer-lasting than non-stick options, reducing the need for frequent replacements and further reducing waste.

Companies like Caraway are leading the way in sustainable and non-toxic bakeware production.

Caraway bakeware is made by a manufacturing process that releases 60% less co2 into the atmosphere compared to the production of traditional nonstick pans and they package responsibly! Using recycled cardboard and low-impact dyes.

By choosing sustainable bakeware options, we not only prioritize our health but also contribute to a healthier planet.

What are the Traditional Bakeware Materials to Avoid?

Aluminum

One of the most common toxic materials found in bakeware brands is aluminum. Aluminum bakeware is popular due to its excellent heat conductivity, but the cons outweigh the pros if you ask me! Aluminum reacts with acidic foods like the tomato sauce in your ratatouille and leaches toxic materials into your food. High levels of aluminum in the body have been linked to neurological problems and other health problems. They’ll say, “Bon appetit!” But you’ll know better! 

There are now “souped up” versions of aluminum bakeware on the market today called anodized aluminum, but this process does not guarantee a food-safe material. If it’s up to me, I avoid aluminum altogether. 

Ceramic

Ceramic glazes are another type of bakeware that can contain toxic materials like lead and cadmium. These substances can leach into your food when heated, causing serious health problems over time. Not to mention, these pieces are often improperly fired which can be even more dangerous.

Non-Stick

Another potentially toxic material found in bakeware is non-stick coatings made with perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA). These coatings are often used in baking sheets and pans, and they can release toxic fumes when heated. These fumes have been linked to environmental problems as well as various health problems, including cancer, thyroid disease, and developmental problems in children.

Conclusion

Non toxic bakeware is the safest option for both our health and the environment.

By saying no to exposure to harmful chemicals, you can enjoy the benefits of safe and sustainable baking!

With the best non-toxic bakeware picks of 2023, you can bake with confidence and peace of mind.

Happy baking!